Alternate Billing of Attorney Fees in Federal Disability Retirement Applications and Appeals

Around the internet, you will read advice that tells youfee.
to negotiate attorney fees with your attorney, or to4) Retainers and Hourly Billing: This is the most
inquire about alternate billing methods to save youtraditional method that attorneys use to charge for
money in your federal disability retirement application ortheir services. You pay a sum, called a retainer, to the
appeal. Usually, however, the article stops there. Hereattorney. That retainer is held in a Trust Account (in
is a summary of some of the different types of feeTexas, they are called IOLTA accounts). Periodically,
structures that are available. Before starting, however,the attorney takes money out of the trust account for
it is helpful to understand that certain fee structureshours worked and fees expended. The amount that
may not be appropriate for your case and may endthe attorney takes out is based on the number of
up costing you more than you expect. Other feehours worked in that period times the hourly rate that
structures might be unlawful (in Texas, for example, ityou and the federal disability retirement lawyer agreed
is illegal to charge a contingency rate for a criminal lawto. If your retainer runs low, or reaches an agreed on
case).thresh-hold, you will have to replenish the retainer.
1) Consultation Fee: This is the first fee that you mightMany Firms are moving to what is called the
run across as you look for a federal or postal disability"evergreen retainer", where the client is required to
retirement lawyer. Most Firms that charge this fee doautomatically replenish the retainer to a certain dollar
so to cover the costs and time involved in evaluatingamount any time it reaches a certain dollar amount.
your case. Not every firm does charge a consultationThe plus side of an hourly fee arrangement is that if
fee, however. If you are not paying a consultation fee,the attorney doesn't spend all of the retainer, the
you are probably not getting any specific legal advicefederal employee or postal worker client will receive a
about your situation; you are probably getting arefund of the unused portion. The down side is that
cookie-cutter type analysis meant to help the attorneythese types of fees are usually unpredictable, and can
or Firm assess if they want to go further. This isn't aget quite expensive, particularly when an attorney has
bad thing - certain types of cases lend themselvesa higher hourly rate.
well to such an approach.A word about hourly rates: hourly rates are set by an
2) Contingency Fee: This type of fee arrangementattorney or a firm based on its own internal
occurs where the law firm agrees to represent you, incalculations and policies. The hourly rate can vary
exchange for a percentage of any recovery. Usually,drastically from city to city.
that percentage will range from 20% to 45%. If it isFor example, the hourly rate at my firm is generally
any lower, you should be suspicious: this amount wouldcomputed by totaling the costs of running the law
usually not be enough to fairly compensate anoffice (hiring staff, equipment, office space, storage
attorney for his or her time on a case, so you shouldspace, copiers, computers, fax machines, insurance,
be wary of the old adage that you get what you payetc.) divided by the number of hours the Firm needs to
for. If it is any higher than 45%, you should bebe open for clients. Because it is cheaper to run a law
extremely suspicious - I have only heard ofoffice in Dallas, Texas than in Washington, D.C., the
contingency arrangements higher than 45% of theaverage hourly rate of an attorney in Dallas should be
award in a select few cases. Read the language on alower than a similar attorney in Washington, D.C. Many
contingency fee contract carefully. While not having toattorneys are maligned for high hourly fees - the
pay costs up front, you will likely have to pay costs outgreater public thinks we get rich off our hourly rates -
of your share of the award. Be wary of firms thatnot true. I agree that some of the big firms tend to
charge you a percentage of your future disabilityhave unusually high or exorbitant hourly rates; for most
retirement benefits - this is an unusual practice andsmall law firms, boutique or niche practices, or solo
hamstrings the federal retiree on a fixed income.practitioners, the hourly rate is just enough to keep the
3) Fixed Fees: Some attorneys will agree to representpower on and the phones ringing.
you in your MSPB appeal or application to OPM for a5) Engagement Retainers: More and more law firms
fixed fee. This type of fee is a one-time fee that youare using engagement retainers. This type of retainer,
pay to the attorney in exchange for legalalso called a True Retainer, is a one-time payment to a
representation. The attorney's representation is strictlyfirm or attorney which enables them to make time
limited, in terms of time or scope. For example, aavailable to represent you (and not some other client).
Federal Disability Retirement lawyer may charge aThe Firm and the client anticipate getting attorney fees
federal employee or postal worker a fixed fee for thepaid later (usually through some sort of fee-shifting
first application for federal disability retirement. Onceprovision), and so the Engagement Retainer is a
the application is filed, the representation is over, unlesspayment that is consideration for keeping the time
you agree to something different. The fixed fee canopen to be available to work a case.
be a monthly fee for each month that your case goes6) Blended Arrangements: Any one or more of the
on, or one fee for the whole application, or one fee forabove approaches can be blended together. At my
the MSPB appeal: there are unlimited ways that aFirm, for example, we charge Federal employees and
fixed-fee approach can be structured to help fit yourpostal workers a fixed fee for the first application for
budget needs and the attorneys need to run adisability retirement, and other fees for the MSPB
business. The nice thing about a fixed-fee is that itappeal phase (depending on the client's needs, ability to
fixes your legal costs to a known dollar amount. Thepay, and the facts and complexity of the particular
down side? Fixed fees can, in complex cases, becase, etc.) Blended arrangements are more and more
somewhat high, as the attorney or law firm does notcommon - attorneys as an industry are striving to find
want to run the risk that they will put more time anda balance between affordable legal representation and
costs into the case than they can recover with a fixedcovering the high costs associate with a law practice.