Dance With the Devil - All the Downfalls of Hiring From Direct Competition

Recruiting From Direct Competition - Not Always thethis type of hiring. We do not. Additionally, when I get
Best Way to Gothese types of requests, one thought comes to mind.
I want to start off this article by saying that yourWhy does this client believe that their competition is
competition should be your enemy. Competition is whatbetter than their company or has more talented
drives competition. It feeds on itself. If you are lookingemployees? If you can identify specific reasons why
to hire one of three main competitors for a salesyour company falls behind others in the industry, focus
position, there is something wrong with your companyon making internal improvements. These internal
mentality.shortfalls can include your products or services, your
"The wise learn many things from their enemies."management team or your sales representatives. If
- Aristophanesyou have the perception that the competition is better,
About once a month, our recruiting firm receives a callundoubtedly there are some issues which need
from a company who wants us to find them animmediate attention within your organization.
employee from a few specific companies whichThen, only after getting the aforementioned done,
happen to be their direct competition - usually, they likeconsider bringing someone in from the outside. Though,
to target about three. More or less, these potentialbe smart and find someone better than what the
clients want us to cold-call into their competitors'competition has. In business, hiring a competitor is like
offices and target every sales person at thesehaving dinner with the enemy. More times than not,
companies in order to solicit the job to them one bybringing in a competitor make your current employees
one. Without exception, we turn down these requestsuneasy. Also, the sheer willingness to from competitor
as time on our side would better be spent throwing ato competitor (corporate traitor as such) does not
baseball in the park. Many recruiters will attempt to fulfillallude to the fact that this person is exceedingly loyal.
these requests by having their lower level employeesThat's not always the case, but it's harder to convince
begin harassing sales representatives at these targetsomebody that you are not a criminal while wearing
companies with frequent emails and phone calls.handcuffs. Each business is unique and has its
When it comes to this facet of recruiting, let's face it:strengths and weaknesses. Different does mean
nobody in their right mind (and our competitors arebetter or worse. Celebrate your company's own
smart enough) is going to have their "A-Squad"distinct way of operating.
cold-calling every sales representative in a company inFinally, even if you are able to find an employee from
the hopes that someone will move from Maryland toa direct competitor who is willing to interview for the
New York because of a $10,000 signing bonus. Whenposition, you have to consider why they might be quite
trying to recruit from the competition, recruiters andeager to leave their current company. Our recruiters
employers are bound to run into several problems.have often found that the sales representatives who
Also, the majority of the time, beginning an employeeare actually interested in leaving their job are either
search with these parameters ends up doing moreperforming poorly at their current firm or have
bad than good; this is for all parties involved.alternative motives for having a conversation with
Upon getting a phone call from a new client who,someone within your business. Be careful of
unknowingly to me, represents a firm with these"candidates" who are just fishing for inside information.
ghastly HR ideas. Though, it is nice of them as theyTreat your direct competitors as the enemy and don't
don't waste my time. When it comes to an "employeebe envious of what they have. Focus on beating them
stealing" account, before the full conversation begins,at their own game.
the person on the other line promptly inquiries if we do